Sunday, January 2, 2011

Harry Hay's Writings, Part 2: Should we be considered individuals or be considered a group?


“Should we be considered individuals or be considered a group?”

To foster dialogue at the discussion groups, the Mattachine organizers often prepared comments and questions. The following are two examples of brief remarks that Hay presented at discussion groups in the 1951-1952 period. They give a good idea of the level of dialogue at these meetings.
Here again Hay emphasizes the need for homosexuals to understand themselves if they expect to win the understanding of heterosexuals. At the same time, although the defensive tone of the 1948 prospectus is largely gone, the preoccupation with self-destructive Gay behavior is still apparent. One of Hay's arguments for the minority thesis in this period was that Gays needed a culture, a community, to provide them with social standards and mores that would lead them away from anti-social behaviors. At the same time, Hay's use of the term "heteros," a reversal of the derogatory use of "homos," reflects the extent to which his sense of belonging to a minority had sharpened. He also offers a critique of heterosexual chauvinism that anticipates the 1980s analysis of heterosexism.


"Should we be considered individuals or be considered a group?"

Social Directions of the Homosexual

The public sees any Homosexual as a member of a group - a group which is characterized, in their minds, by people who stand around at parties and discuss their physical attributes, exhibit exhibitionism and callousness, and are as a whole degenerate. Heterosexuals, as well, talk openly of sex - the major difference being the gender of the sex and the implicative end-products of that sex. But this difference does not necessarily enter into the heterosexual's consideration and evaluation of the Homosexuals.
This situation should be a challenge to Homosexuals who have the capability to better their social habits. It should also be remembered that there is no separation of groups (as bull-sessions and tea-parties in heterosexual culture) and therefore Homosexuals need be all the more concerned in developing ethical standards to curb licentious conversations.
A Homosexual need not choose any ethic or responsibility, which often he does not, though as a result he sinks into degeneration and frustration. He chooses no ethical responsibility, and therefore he simultaneously chooses, by implication, not to belong to society.
In heterosexuality it is to be expected that there should be a stress on sexual matters because this is connected with their primary concern – reproduction - and thus is directive. The Homosexual copies this pattern and because it is not applicable, and nondirective, he is considered loose and degenerate. When the sex urge is thus not meaningfully used for procreation, this energy should be channelized elsewhere where its end can be creativity. Some societies have put this into practice, such as those people who deny sex to those creative workmen building canoes until their job is finished. Sex drains power that could be constructively put to use in other areas. This is especially lamentable in the case of the Homosexual, where unproductive sex becomes overemphasized and a basis for frustration. 
Homosexuals are "lone wolves" through fear. In society as it now stands, they congratulate themselves for not being caught, as have their less fortunate brothers, and understandably retreat more within themselves. Like any human, the Homosexual has many things he wants not to be forced to face. Thus he is often an escapist. A Homosexual has no one to whom he must account, and in the end as well he must decide everything for himself. Though, in some instances, this is equally true of the heterosexual ... the process for the latter is infinitely easier because the heterosexual has a socially predetermined pattern to follow and the opportunity to solicit upon it adequate guidance.
Though ethics are arrived at by the group, they are meaningful only when applied by the individual himself. It is essential that Homosexuals begin to direct their thinking in this way. Ghetto walls can be knocked down, but cooperation is essential. There are, however, difficulties to be overcome. Those in greatest need are sometimes the most reluctant to help each other or themselves, tending rather to think of personal experiences as things apart from the mutual effort toward betterment. Still others are not to be trusted until they have been shown the best way to overcome their difficulties. Heterosexuals have the opportunity to have their differences out with each other and thus are enabled to get along in relative harmony, but Homosexuals find this impossible and carry grudges and find freedom of expression impossible.
Homosexuals do not understand themselves and thus it is not surprising that heterosexuals do not understand them either. Because of pent-up frustrations and resentments the Homosexual psychologically rebels and becomes catty and takes on other characteristics of instability. Each person considers himself terribly maladjusted and peculiar. There is now no positive body of information from well-adjusted people.1 Rather we find case histories of psychopathic and extreme cases that are negative and retrogressive.
Some glad day there should be a body of knowledge that would mean aid and progression, in that it would show that Homosexuals, as a group, have much in common and that they are not unique cases. Should we be considered individuals or be considered a group? We are essentially a group of individuals that have been forced together by society. Society attacks the Homosexuals for their non-conformity in sexual desire and objects completely on the basis of this one characteristic. This attitude would change if society could see the positive side and realize the potential ability to offer a worthwhile contribution.
Homosexuals as a group are composed of a cross-section of society, and thus all types of individuals may be found within the group. There are those few individualists who find it possible to cope with the status-quo and make for themselves a stable niche. The fact remains, however, that the majority of Homosexuals are inept at adjusting without an acceptable atmosphere and an adequate pattern.

Dated October 4, 1951.  Delivered at a Mattachine discussion group.


Homosexual Values versus Community Prejudices

…To return to an examination of the basic American language and culture, we must realize that in the average consciousness humanity is divided into just two classifications-and that's all. Male and Female. Countries are fatherlands or motherlands. Ships are feminine. All living forms unless actually designated as feminine are spoken of in the singular as masculine. For example, "every person in the audience wore his overcoat." Not only has this primitive over-simplification persecuted and defeated the Homosexual in every attempt to bridge the gap between his minority and the mainstream of social contribution, but this oversimplification has become the root of the hetero community's stupid hysteria concerning our threat to themselves. 

1. The stereotype is a stark and vicious example of the hetero's attempt to explain our social conduct and appearance in terms of black or white-that is, MALE or FEMALE.

2. The Homosexual, in these terms, as a lover of the male sex, must therefore be a feminine-man. If he loves his own sex-he therefore loves men. Thus, in the public mind, he is in competition with women and with the social objective of holy wedlock and with the eternal objective of the reproducing family.

The hetero's primitive over-simplification has an equally disastrous effect on us, too. Through the pressures of daily conditioning in language and culture we, too, accept the social stereotype that humanity is either male or female. And because it is our compulsion to love males-we perforce allow ourselves to be caricatured as feminine.

1. The latter is too much of an over-simplification. I should say we either allow ourselves to be caricatured as feminine, or we waste our days running around trying to persuade 85 the world that we are 100% he-men studs with real balls. What's so important about this? Who arewe trying to kid? Does this help society to accept homosexuality with any better grace?

2. How do we explain, not in person, but to that vast audience whom we will never see-known as the general public-that in the main we, like all Minorities, prefer the company and the intimacy of our own? That the men to whom we are attracted are Homosexual Men?

To tell them is a beginning-but to explain means to make them understand it in their terms-to justify it so that they can add it up in their values. HOW DO WE DO IT? I would like to throw out some general questions which might begin to find answers for all this:

1. Obviously, in order to learn to write these things in terms we know are understandable, we must have spoken them first-and gotten comprehension from heterosexuals. THUS how do we explain ourselves to our parents? How do we explain ourselves to our friends?

2. How do we explain our opposite attractions, the types-we go for, in terms of male and female? Try it.

3. What are we doing when we try to convey the impression that we're 100% men with real balls?

4. How can we each of us begin to fight anti-homosexuality? - in terms of vicious stereotype jokes (particularly tie this in with anti-Semitism)

- in terms of refusing to evade the word Homosexual in order to begin to restore to it some measure of dignity
- in terms of our use of chauvinist words-supplanting "normal" with "heterosexual"

Delivered at a Mattachine discussion group, August 1952.

Note

1.      1.  This was the premise of Evelyn Hooker's research, which effectively countered the claim
that Gay men were psychologically maladjusted.

Monday, December 13, 2010

The Writings of Harry Hay: Bachelors Anonymous

I'm currently transcribing some of the Harry Hay's writings, some of the earliest American texts on queer liberation, for the web.  They are insightful not only for the political orientation they reveal, but as a foundation from which we can orient the current state of the the movement.  This particular text is perhaps the earliest written document we have of the how pre-Stonewall LGBT people conceived of themselves and how and why they should organize for their own liberation.  These writings can be found in Radically Gay: Gay Liberation in the Words of its Founder, Harry Hay, edited by Will Roscoe.
  
   - LL





Preliminary Concepts:  International Bachelors Fraternal Order for Peace & Social Dignity, Sometimes referred to as Bachelors Anonymous.

A service and welfare organization devoted to the protection and improvement of Society’s Androgynous Minority.

A.  Statement of aims and purposes.
      1.  With full realization that encroaching American Fascism, like unto previous impacts of International Fascism, seeks to bend unorganized and unpopular minorities into isolated fragments of social and emotional instability;
With full realization that the socially censured Androgynous Minority was suborned, blackmailed, cozened, and stampeded into serving as hoodlums, stool pigeons, volunteer informers, concentration camp trustees, torturers, and hangmen, before it, as a minority, was ruthlessly exterminated;
With full realization that the full significance of the government indictment against Androgynous Civil Servants, veiled under the sentiment that they "by the peculiar Circumstances of their private lives lay themselves wide open to social blackmail by a Foreign Power," lies in the legal establishment of a second type of GUILT BY ASSOCIATION;
With the full realization that a GUILT BY ASSOCIATION charge requires that the victim prove himself innocent against undisclosed charges (and is, therefore, impossible), and that a GUILT BY ASSOCIATION charge can be leveled on the evidence of anonymous and malicious informers (and, therefore, cannot be fought), and that under the Government's announced plans for eventual 100% war production mobilization all commerce and production would be conducted under government contract - thus making it impossible for Androgynes to secure employment;
And with the full realization that Guilt of Androgynity BY ASSOCIATION, equally with Guilt of Communist sympathy BY ASSOCIATON, can be employed as a threat against any and every man and woman in our country as a whip to ensure thought control and political regimentation;
With the full realization that, in order to earn for ourselves any place in the sun, we must with perseverance and self-discipline work collectively on the side of peace, for the program of the four freedoms of the Atlantic Charter, and in the spirit and letter of the United Nations Charter, for the full first-class citizenship participation of Minorities everywhere, including ourselves;
            We, the Androgynes of the world, have formed this responsible corporate body to demonstrate by our efforts that our physiological and psychological handicaps need be no deterrent in integrating 10% of the world's population towards the constructive social progress of mankind.

      2.  We declare our aims to be to effect socially, economically, politically, and morally, the integration of the best interests of the Androgynous minority with the common good of the community in which we live.

      3.  We declare our aims to present the concept of our Fraternal Orders, fully subscribed to by our membership, as being similar in both membership service and community service and social objectives as the well-known and respected “Alcoholics Anonymous.”

      4.  We aim, by helping our members to adjust emotionally and intellectually to the enlightened mores and ethics of the standard community, to eradicate the vicious myths and taboos that physiological deviation (degeneracy in its true scientific sense) precludes psychological and social degeneracy. (Within the recognized minorities, people are bad not because they are Jews or Negroes but because of the external nature of their political and economic environments. We must endeavor to understand ourselves and then demonstrate this knowledge to the community.)

      5.  We aim to aid in the dispelling of this myth by attempting to regulate the social conduct of our minority in such matters as, for example, exhibitionism, indiscriminate profligacy, violations of public decency; we aim to explore and promote a socially healthy approach to the ethical values of a constructed pairing between Androgynes; we aim to tackle the question of profligacy and Satyriasis as emotional diseases to be treated clinically.

      6.  We aim to dispel the fears and antagonisms of the community by making available clinical personnel, specialists, and apparati to educators, churchmen, and professional practitioners to the end of discovering and applying group or personal techniques of therapy and/
or guidance, to give advice or recommendations or assistance to outside community bodies perplexed by manifestations of an Androgynous nature or character; we aim by the above equipment to help curb the malingering and the inducements professed to be common to cases of juvenile delinquents; we aim by the above equipment to help community organizations adjust and alleviate where possible the emotional and psychological development of Androgynous tendencies in minors.

       7.  We aim, by making available to biologists, physiochemists, psychologists, and educators, clinical experience and data on the objectives, frustrations, daily patterns, oppressions, insecurities, compromises, and fruitions of the great body of average Androgynes, to represent to the community a codified social analysis upon which constructive and progressive sexual legislation may be comprehended and enacted.

      8. We aim to contribute to the general welfare of the community by making common cause with other minorities in contributing to the reform of judicial, police, and penal practices which undermine the honesty and morale of the community.

      9. We aim to contribute to the general morale of the community by bringing ourselves to realize that only in a national community embodying the right to freedom of conscience, the right to the expression of personal opinion, and the objective of a peaceful and mutually cooperative world affording equal place to cultural production as to industrial production can our minority realize and contribute its full value.

    10. We aim to integrate ourselves into the constructive social progress of society, on the side of peace, for the program of the four freedoms of the Atlantic Charter, and in the spirit and letter of the United Nations Charter, by providing a collective outlet for political, cultural, and social expression to some 10% of the world's population, in which the collective force of their vote and voice may have substance and value.

B.  Activities.
1. A Service Organization providing:
a. Committee channels to work for positive, scientifically predicated, and morale
building legislation.
b. Committee channels to fight against, and eliminate, police brutality, political
and judicial shakedown, and civic blackmail.
c. Committee channels to educate public opinion.
d. Committee channels to supplement community campaigns for minority rights; for safeguarding and restoring Constitutional Democracy on every Level; for promoting and insuring International Peace and the self-determination of nations and national minorities.
e. Committee channels to make available to the community whatever apparatus we may develop which has valuable community application (see A-6, 7, 8; see also B-3 below).

2. A Civil Insurance Organization providing:
a. Through dues payments and standard computed fees, legal services for all civil infractions, shake-downs, frame-ups, blackmail, slander, and unwarranted invasions of personal privacy, as applicable legally to Androgynous experience.
b. Through standard fees, bail in all cases, preliminary to review by the Orders' Grievance Committee to determine if the action involves any of the protectable categories outlined in B-1 above.
(1) If clause 8-1 is invoked, the Orders' insurance is to cover all basic costs of the case.
(2) If clause B-I is NOT invoked, the Orders' insurance does not apply. (But the Orders' Service and Welfare Committees will endeavor to work and press for judicial and community leniency, and will offer to take such cases under guardianship and apply therapy or guidance under the jurisdiction and supervision of the Court.)
(3) If clause B- I is invoked, the Order will make every effort to safeguard the social and economic well-being of the member and will undertake rehabilitation if necessary.

3. A Welfare and Educational Organization providing:
a. Educational Study groups and membership Forums on the issues which concern the civic responsibilities, general welfare campaigns, and constitutional requirements of the community as a whole, IN WHICH THE MEMBERSHIP BY ITS AIMS REQUIRES THE RIGHT TO PARTICIPATE.
b. Educational study groups and membership Forums on the special issues which the Order is sworn to promote and promulgate.
c. Cultural, creative, and recreational activities towards the end of improving the social conditions of culture, under the organizing impact of craftsman-and-audience constant participation.
d. Welfare groups to promote a better social integration of the membership Minority into the community-at-large:
(1) This shall include series of group discussions on ethics, hygiene, ethnology, social anthropology, social custom, morality, genetics, etc.
(2) This shall include therapeutic groups conducted in accordance with the most
advanced available techniques.
(3) This shall include scholastic and laboratory research into the most advanced
physiological and psychological theories, techniques, and applications, for the benefit of membership needs and aims, and the needs of the community as a whole.
(4) This shall include committees and flying squads of specialists and qualified
personnel, available for individual membership needs and problems, available to community needs and problems, and available to judiciary and governmental consultations, paroles, suspensions, and guardianships.
e. First Aid squads and single volunteers on a 24-hour basis to provide therapy, guidance, or counsel to members in emotional and psychological distress,
f. Social Service Committee to help new members, and members new to this community, to adjust themselves to the duties, the responsibilities, and the privileges of the local Orders Chapter.
g. Public Relations Committee composed of civic advisors, churchmen, attorneys, doctors, qualified members, and interested persons to suggest activities and services based on current community interests.
h. The above suggested activities may be carried on under close supervision on a cooperative or token fee basis as determined by the membership body of the Chapter.

C. Membership.
1. Membership shall be declared to be completely non-discriminatory as to race, color, creed, or political affiliation and shall be limited only to those actively affirming the principles of majority democracy, practiced within the Order, as outlined in A-I above.
2. Membership shall be anonymous to the community at large and to each other if they choose:  membership shall be protected by the device of fictitious names until such times as the organization is in a position to incorporate and set into operation the Civil Insurance plan.
3. Membership and inter-Order activity shall be Masonic in character; shall be understood to be sworn to protective secrecy except inasmuch as certain aims, purposes, and committees shall be declared as parties to community action or campaign.
4. Membership shall be determined by member-recommendation only and shall be confirmed by election.  Members shall enter an initiate period for one year before being confirmed and during this period the Civil Insurance Coverage shall apply only at the discretion of the Executive Board. (Mechanics to be further determined.)
5. Membership shall, at all times, require of members and initiate an established minimum of active and unsolicited participation in at least one Educational-Welfare activity and one Service activity of the Orders' Chapter.
6. Membership shall be classified into five degrees of rank which shall be determined and bestowed by membership vote.
a. Initiate Degree:  Insignia pin showing IBFO
b. First Degree (requirement: recognized participation in Service & Welfare activity):  Insignia pin showing IBFO bar showing Androgyne (in Greek)
c. Second Degree (requirement:  achievement in community recognition activity):  Insignia pin showing IBFO bar showing Berdache (in Hopi)
d.  Third Degree (requirement:  continual leadership in Orders’ Aims and Purposes):  Insignia pin showing IBFO bar design designating Order of St. Medardus
e. Fourth Degree (requirement: the highest honor bestowable):  Insignia pin and bars as described before, plus escutcheon and chain showing the Egyptian Ankh, the sign of the Order of Pharoah, the historic personification of the Angrogynous ideal

7. Membership shall agree to at all times, whether able to be involved or not, to lend a willing ear and voice to programs and purposes considered basic to the described objectives of the Orders.

8. Membership shall agree that at all times leadership principles and activity principles shall be weighed and accepted in terms of their adherence to the objectives, in spirit and in letter, as described in section A-1 above.  Membership shall agree that at any time it becomes apparent that membership activity and sentiment is not in accord with the objectives and principles described in A above, that the dissenting member is required to submit his resignation, that the dissenting chapter is considered suspended preliminary to dissolution by the Executive Board, or that the organization as a whole is required to dissolve its incorporation and any and all connections with or interest in the name and prestige of this organization.

9. Membership shall subscribe to a minimum program of mutual aid and assistance, particularly to members who are new to a group or to a community.  Similarly to Shrine and Masonic practice, insignia worn at an unconventional angle may be used to designate distress or need ---and must be acted upon by all other members as quickly as possible.

D. Details of Organization (tentative and as yet incomplete).
1. The Orders shall be incorporated under the laws, duties and proscriptions attached to such non-profit organizations.  Its corporate charter and by-laws must incorporate very precisely the objective and limitations of Section A and be subject to the proscriptions indicated in
Section C-8.

2. The Orders shall be conceived to sub-charter supplementary subsidiaries such as:
            a. International Spinsters Orders.
            b. International Friends and Well-Wishers Auxiliaries.
            c. etc.

3. The Orders shall seek the aid and support of Church and Professional and Civic Leaders. The Orders shall seek the aid, and in return shall subscribe to the support of governmental reform bodies in the community; the Orders shall seek the cooperation and respect of all minority groups, physical and moral welfare groups, and any other groups, whose general aims and purposes both nationally and internationally-subscribe to the objectives described in A above.

4. The Orders declare that, at all times, they publicly subscribe (though anonymously except through the public face of the Orders) to the aims, tenets, and objectives described in Section A. If any individual, group, Chapter, or Division deny or betray by intent or action any and/or several of these tenets at any time, the Orders reserve the rights to dissolve and expel the offending Chapters or members, and shall do everything in its power to make social restitution for the offenses (see C-8; D-II).

5. For purposes of mutual protection and supervision, all inter-order activities and meetings shall be declared as "closed" to membership only, except as they may be singly designated for community assistance services or campaigns by the Majority decision of the Membership involved, at each instance and each occasion.

6. Meetings and committees shall be designed for compactness and mobility ... and shall be closely supervised to insure optimal subscription to the basic requirements of community behavior. Membership recreational activities, in the name of the organization, shall be planned and designed with the amenabilities and censures of the community in mind. (For example, play-party and square dancing will probably be always acceptable where social dancing might not.)

7. Groups shall be mainly geographical except in regard to recreational and welfare groups as outlined in B-3 above.

8. Membership Lists shall be planned with the Optimal Anonymity in mind; after full and protective incorporation has been executed membership lists in coded fictions and all data shall be handled by a bonded officer appointed by a duly elective and supervising governing committee.

9. The Orders, for the time being, shall be self-supporting as to needed funds and fees, and shall seek the services of paid functionaries ONLY when the scope of Organizational activity requires it.

10. Insignia, referred to in C-6, must be EARNED by the member, and shall be bestowed by elective vote only in respect to degree of participatory service upon the part of the candidate. a. Any member who shall, in the course of a year, not advance the degree of his standing must agree to a review of his privileges and responsibilities and must agree to attempt to reach common decision with the committee as to his future commitments. b. This shall be construed as one of a number of safeguards of the protective mantle required by the Orders against the infiltration of elements inimicable to the aims and principles of the Orders and its individual members.

11. In relation to the public responsibility assured by the Orders as indicated in D-4, and cross-references above, it must be understood that should investigation reveal that the violation were a first deviation, or an irrational or compulsive slip from the self-discipline sought and subscribed to by the Orders that the organization reserves the right to treat the member, or members, as penitents and to invoke the protection of therapeutic guardianship under the leniency of the community.

All the above, with the exception of the general sense and social orientation indicated in section A, is declared to be purely exploratory and open to complete expansion or rejection.
Respectfully submitted to whom it may concern ...
Eann MacDonald
Dated July 7,1950, but actually typed July 9.

Notes
1. Stuart Timmons, The Trouble with Harry Hay: Founder of the Modern Gay Movement (Boston: Alyson, 1990), pp. 132,135.
2.  Hay believes that Chuck Rowland burned the last copy during an episode of depression following the break-up of the original movement.
3. When I asked Hay about the role of women in early Mattachine, he provided me with the following recollections: "Del Martin and Phyl Lyons, next to Helen Sanders (Helen Sandoz) and Sten Russell (Stella Rush), their counterparts and first Editors of The Ladder, who moved from SF to LA in about 1956, were typical of the Lesbians who came forward at all during the first decade. Ruth Bernhard, who became a world-renowned photographer in the late'50s and '60S, was a major exception:  a truly marvelous European-born and -educated Woman, who was totally sure of herself as an artist as well as a person. Ruth was introduced to us through Martin Block's friend, the actor Phil Jones, and his actor-director friend Paul Bennard in approximately September of 1951.  Geraldean Jackson (whose neighborhood name was Betty Purdue) had become part of the Echo Park-Silverlake Guild after the trial, in the Fall of 1952, and she, in turn, brought Jim Kepner to his first Mattachine Discussion Group meeting in late December of 1952 or early 1953. After ONE mag started, Ann Carll Reid and her lover Dawn Fredrick (who became Eve Elloree and ONE's Art Director) showed up, with Ann Carll taking over the editorship from Dale Jennings after ONE's first year in 1954. With the exception of 'Boopsie,' who showed up with Hal Call from San Francisco during the gathering of the First Mattachine's rupturous upheaval in April-May of 1953, these are all the women I know about in first Mattachine" (pers. comm., April 27, 1995).
4. The Atlantic Charter was a program of peace aims and a statement on international human rights enunciated by Churchill and Roosevelt in August 1941, which became the basis for the formation of the United Nations.
5.  In the 1930s, a friend of Hay who had traveled through the Balkans showed him a small carving of a saint honored in that region named Medardus (or Medardos in Greek), who was the patron of life-long male companions. There is a French St. Medard, but I have been unable to confirm if this is the same figure Hay identifies.